Debatable Decisions table.

You are not connected. Please login or register

Debatable Decisions table.

Rick Rosstrich

Rick Rosstrich: Posts: 26595
Age: 84

Post n°1

Debatable Decisions table.

by Rick Rosstrich on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:34 pm

We all get annoyed with referees bad decisions and we wonder what the league would be like had the decisions not been given. We also like to know how many debatable decisions have gone against us and for us.

So here is the debatable decisions table for the Premier League:

And this is what the table would look like had there been no debatable decisions.

Not fully conclusive because penalties still have to be scored etc..

http://www.debatabledecisions.com/

_________________

Guest: Guest

Post n°2

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Guest on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:42 pm

I would love to see one of those for Scotland. Interesting that.

kyro7: Posts: 61337
Age: 19

Post n°3

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by kyro7 on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:43 pm

Fergie Association.

_________________

'09 Australian Open Final. not worthy

not worthy

Big_Lad_Pardew: Formerly known as: Big_Lad_Taylor
Posts: 3230

Post n°4

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Big_Lad_Pardew on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:43 pm

They have turned something subjective into data represented in a table.... Bravo.

Gatsby: Formerly known as: Sean
Posts: 29558
Age: 18
Location: West Egg
Supports: prohibition :shifty:

Post n°5

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Gatsby on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:44 pm

Depends on what they deem as a debatable decision, cant really take it without seeing the incidents they mean

Rick Rosstrich

Rick Rosstrich: Posts: 26595
Age: 84

Post n°6

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Rick Rosstrich on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:45 pm

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:They have turned something subjective into data represented in a table.... Bravo.

All these ones are conclusive. They were just debatable at the time, like penalties that weren't given, Shawcross becoming a goalkeeper against Spurs and shit like that.

shifty

shifty

_________________

Rick Rosstrich

Rick Rosstrich: Posts: 26595
Age: 84

Post n°7

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Rick Rosstrich on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:47 pm

DISCLAIMER – Please be aware that we are not trying to pass the REAL table off as fact, we are more than aware of certain flawed aspects, however, we would hope that everyone reading takes it in good nature and employs the imagination needed to enjoy a fun and unnusual take on the Premier League and refereeing decisions. If you take it too seriously, or mistakenely believe that we are taking it too seriously, you’re missing out.
We would also like to draw your attention to the the Decisions Table, which we consider the most important and accurate table on Debatable Decisions. The decisions are judged by five independent judges, who each support different club sides (ranging from the Premier League to League One) and all decisions are discussed in the blogs provided under Referee Analysis. Before and after is not taken into account, it is simply a table of incorrect decision for and against each team in the Premier League.

_________________

Big_Lad_Pardew: Formerly known as: Big_Lad_Taylor
Posts: 3230

Post n°8

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Big_Lad_Pardew on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:48 pm

Mal wrote:
Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:They have turned something subjective into data represented in a table.... Bravo.

All these ones are conclusive. They were just debatable at the time, like penalties that weren't given, Shawcross becoming a goalkeeper against Spurs and shit like that.

There are very few clear cut decisions like that. But even still, there is no way of saying how they would have affected the game.

Rick Rosstrich

Rick Rosstrich: Posts: 26595
Age: 84

Post n°9

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Rick Rosstrich on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:48 pm

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:
Mal wrote:
Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:They have turned something subjective into data represented in a table.... Bravo.

All these ones are conclusive. They were just debatable at the time, like penalties that weren't given, Shawcross becoming a goalkeeper against Spurs and shit like that.

There are very few clear cut decisions like that. But even still, there is no way of saying how they would have affected the game.

Disclaimer above. shifty

shifty

_________________

Alan: Posts: 7013
Location: Retirement home i think
Supports: LIVERPOOL FOOTBALL CLUB AND KING KENNETH

Post n°10

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Alan on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:48 pm

Does that also add things like the Wolves player who was sent off against Arsenal, terrible decision that was. And a few other decision's like this that have went for and against lots of teams.

Big_Lad_Pardew: Formerly known as: Big_Lad_Taylor
Posts: 3230

Post n°11

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Big_Lad_Pardew on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:50 pm

Mal wrote:DISCLAIMER – Please be aware that we are not trying to pass the REAL table off as fact, we are more than aware of certain flawed aspects, however, we would hope that everyone reading takes it in good nature and employs the imagination needed to enjoy a fun and unnusual take on the Premier League and refereeing decisions. If you take it too seriously, or mistakenely believe that we are taking it too seriously, you’re missing out.
We would also like to draw your attention to the the Decisions Table, which we consider the most important and accurate table on Debatable Decisions. The decisions are judged by five independent judges, who each support different club sides (ranging from the Premier League to League One) and all decisions are discussed in the blogs provided under Referee Analysis. Before and after is not taken into account, it is simply a table of incorrect decision for and against each team in the Premier League.

Thats like saying.... I have a girlfriend, well actually she is more a he, but if you use your imagination you can use her(him) to have fun

Rick Rosstrich

Rick Rosstrich: Posts: 26595
Age: 84

Post n°12

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Rick Rosstrich on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:51 pm

Big_Lad_Pardew wrote:
Mal wrote:DISCLAIMER – Please be aware that we are not trying to pass the REAL table off as fact, we are more than aware of certain flawed aspects, however, we would hope that everyone reading takes it in good nature and employs the imagination needed to enjoy a fun and unnusual take on the Premier League and refereeing decisions. If you take it too seriously, or mistakenely believe that we are taking it too seriously, you’re missing out.
We would also like to draw your attention to the the Decisions Table, which we consider the most important and accurate table on Debatable Decisions. The decisions are judged by five independent judges, who each support different club sides (ranging from the Premier League to League One) and all decisions are discussed in the blogs provided under Referee Analysis. Before and after is not taken into account, it is simply a table of incorrect decision for and against each team in the Premier League.

Thats like saying.... I have a girlfriend, well actually she is more a he, but if you use your imagination you can use her(him) to have fun

:-.-:

_________________

Theo Filippo: Formerly known as: Filippo Inzaghi
Posts: 16468
Age: 18
Supports: The Craig Whyte Society.

Post n°13

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Theo Filippo on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:53 pm

The Maestro wrote:I would love to see one of those for Scotland. Interesting that.

Yeah it would be really interesting to see if Rangers or Celtic are top

Guest: Guest

Post n°14

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Guest on Sat Jan 14, 2012 5:57 pm

Theo Filippo wrote:
The Maestro wrote:I would love to see one of those for Scotland. Interesting that.
Yeah it would be really interesting to see if Rangers or Celtic are top

It doesn't even have to be "debatable decisions" .. if it were "blatantly obvious wrong decisions" .. then Rangers probably wouldn't even be in the top 3

Rick Rosstrich

Rick Rosstrich: Posts: 26595
Age: 84

Post n°15

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Rick Rosstrich on Sat Jan 14, 2012 6:01 pm

The Maestro wrote:
Theo Filippo wrote:
The Maestro wrote:I would love to see one of those for Scotland. Interesting that.
Yeah it would be really interesting to see if Rangers or Celtic are top

It doesn't even have to be "debatable decisions" .. if it were "blatantly obvious wrong decisions" .. then Rangers probably wouldn't even be in the top 3

Rangers should have had a goal against you. Mischief

Mischief

_________________

Guest: Guest

Post n°16

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Guest on Sat Jan 14, 2012 6:07 pm

Mal wrote:
The Maestro wrote:

It doesn't even have to be "debatable decisions" .. if it were "blatantly obvious wrong decisions" .. then Rangers probably wouldn't even be in the top 3

Rangers should have had a goal against you.

In the last derby? And we had a goal wrongly chopped off for offside

Rick Rosstrich

Rick Rosstrich: Posts: 26595
Age: 84

Post n°17

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Rick Rosstrich on Sat Jan 14, 2012 6:08 pm

The Maestro wrote:
Mal wrote:
The Maestro wrote:

It doesn't even have to be "debatable decisions" .. if it were "blatantly obvious wrong decisions" .. then Rangers probably wouldn't even be in the top 3

Rangers should have had a goal against you.

In the last derby? And we had a goal wrongly chopped off for offside

I thought it was offside?

I don't know...

Hide

Hide

_________________

SBSP: Posts: 42047
Age: 17
Location: In a pineapple under the sea...
Supports: The Celtic Football Club

Post n°18

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by SBSP on Sat Jan 14, 2012 6:44 pm

Mal wrote:
The Maestro wrote:

In the last derby? And we had a goal wrongly chopped off for offside

I thought it was offside?

I don't know...

Gary Hooper was clean through and round the goalkeeper before he stopped for the offside.

Alan: Posts: 7013
Location: Retirement home i think
Supports: LIVERPOOL FOOTBALL CLUB AND KING KENNETH

Post n°19

Re: Debatable Decisions table.

by Alan on Sat Jan 14, 2012 7:18 pm

SBSP wrote:
Mal wrote:

I thought it was offside?

I don't know...

Gary Hooper was clean through and round the goalkeeper before he stopped for the offside.

Totally agree with you Hooper was never offside, but the Rangers goal that was not given would have put them up 1 nil and that could have changed the whole course of the game. Im not complaining as i want Celik to win the League.

Current date/time is Sat May 19, 2012 8:57 am